The Council System Needs a Complete Rework!

Right now, pretty much anyone can submit an idea and get it voted through with the help of their friends, regardless of whether the proposed changes are actually good for the server.

New players and players who aren’t familiar with Vanilla/Classic WoW can push for changes that damage the original Vanilla experience simply because they are impatient or don’t understand what made Vanilla special.

When the server launched, its philosophy was clearly stated:

“Pure Classic Vanilla, a Normal PvE realm — faithful 1.12.1, tuned where it was broken and nowhere else.”

Yet here we are, 150 days later, with unnecessary changes that have already driven many players away.

I believe the Council voting system needs to be restructured around player experience, contribution, and trust.

  1. Voting and proposal eligibility

Players below level 60 should not be allowed to submit proposals or vote in Council polls.

Only established players who have demonstrated a commitment to the server should be able to influence its direction.

  1. Introduce a player trust system

Players should have a trust score or reputation level that reflects their contributions and the quality of their proposals.

+1 trust point for proposals that are successfully implemented.
-1 trust point for one month for proposals that are rejected or fail to get implemented.
+1 trust point for each PvP rank achieved.
+1 trust point for each raid boss kill.
+1 trust point for each world boss kill.

This would help distinguish players who genuinely want to improve the server from those who simply want to push their personal preferences.

  1. Prioritize fixing Vanilla features and existing bugs

The Council should prioritize restoring missing features and fixing existing issues rather than constantly introducing unnecessary changes to Vanilla gameplay.

For example:

Fix cross-faction bugs.
Implement missing features that should have been available from day one.

Final thoughts

The Council should exist to improve the server while preserving its original vision, not to turn it into a completely different version of WoW based on whatever changes happen to be popular at the moment.

We joined this server for a Vanilla 1.12.1 experience. The Council should respect and protect that vision.


Posted from the Council — voting happens there; discuss here.

I miss this from my post:

A Council proposal should only be approved if at least 66% of the votes are YES.

Right now, a proposal can pass by winning by just a single vote. This means that even a 51% majority can force a change that 49% of the voting players disagree with.

For example, if 51 players vote YES and 49 vote NO, the change still goes live. In my opinion, this creates more problems than it solves, especially when it comes to changes that affect the Vanilla experience.

We shouldn’t introduce potentially controversial changes just because they have a narrow majority.

A 66% supermajority would ensure that any major change has broad support from the community before being implemented.

If a proposal fails to reach the 66% threshold, it should not be implemented.

The problem is the Voting system itself.

Proposals that change core mechanics of Vanilla should be summarily rejected as being incompatible with the Stonetavern charter (see: Vanilla with no changes). I would put modifications to Paladin blessings and Warlock Soul Shard stacking into this category of ideas that should have been dismissed and not implemented regardless of voting.

Proposals that close exploits (high level chest camping by low level alts) deserve consideration. Introducing minimum level requirements to even be able to open chests at all (keyed to object number in the database) would solve a lot of these problems.

… you get the idea.
The need for restrictions against such exploits were not necessary before WoW became a “solved game” … but now that it has been, they are necessary to combat exploits.

That way lies madness, I fear. :pensive_face:
Just like how the voting system can be exploited by the few who participate, a “trust system” can be exploited by those determined to Game The System. You’d just be trading one set of hoops to jump through for another.

This is the REAL issue you’re trying to get at.
Personal agendas really do need to take a back seat and know their place.

On this point, at least, we agree.

You need to be careful with the direction of travel you’re taking with your argument. Restoring missing features opens a can of worms.

Agreed.
Not all changes are “good” by default … so long as a majority of the votes are in favor of the changes.

A simple majority for ALL Council votes is inherently problematic.
Supermajorities should be required to modify away from the original Vanilla vision of original Blizzard (circa 2004).

Another problem is that as people join/leave the server(s), changes voted on previously remain in effect, even if the people who voted in favor of those changes no longer participate or contribute to the server(s). Point being that the “electorate” is not static and immutable for all time … what may have been viewed favorably before is not viewed favorably now (because people change their minds about things).

For clarity/simplicity, I would divide proposals into different categories, each needing different thresholds to pass.

  1. Exploits/Bug Fix changes … need majority support (50% + 1) to pass.
  2. Quality of Life changes … need supermajority support (75% + 1) to pass.
  3. Core Mechanics changes … need a unanimous vote (no opposition) to pass.

I would also apply a Minimum Number of Votes Cast to each category, to (help) prevent apathy/disinterest in voting by the many to empower the few determined to take control of the Council voting process.

You were the one trying to vote a revert of all qol with your friends sneakly and failed. You are telling that decision with 60%+ should be accepted, while refusing to accept 64% of people voted for not being able to vote a revert. You are telling that only people with proposion approved should be “trusted” (and raiders, lol…) while you are the one with all proposition rejected.

Can you just stop whining for change you don’t even use and that change absolutely nothing to the game immersion ? People don’t want your stupidly rigid vision of what is vanilla, neither to be censured by people thinking they know better than others what is good for the server. You don’t want to use QOL ? Don’t. I can understand this. But really, stop trying to abuse of the council to impose your vision to everyone.

It’s people like you which make players leave the server. No one never leave because they can stack soul shards, refresh a little less paladin buffs or use tp stone. You are just trying to get what you want, without caring about the server good health or what people want. Just respect the votes.

That’s a big ask when the number of votes cast have been hovering around the 1-5% range of the accounts eligible to be voting.

In order of most recently decided to older decisions:

  • 13 of 1849 eligible accounts took part
  • 22 of 1812 eligible accounts took part
  • 38 of 1742 eligible accounts took part
  • 32 of 1631 eligible accounts took part
  • 117 of 1333 eligible accounts took part
  • 64 of 1387 eligible accounts took part
  • 68 of 1368 eligible accounts took part
  • 34 of 1071 eligible accounts took part
  • 53 of 1041 eligible accounts took part
  • 61 of 1035 eligible accounts took part
  • 58 of 1009 eligible accounts took part
  • 49 of 1041 eligible accounts took part

As you can see, the number of accounts eligible to vote has been going up (recently), but the rate of participation in those votes has been going down.

When all you need is 50%+1 of a mere 1-2% of the eligible accounts to vote in favor of something (anything) … that makes it really easy for self-interested types to capture control over voting. Even doing something as simple as registering multiple accounts and getting 1 character per account to Level 10 (a relatively simple task) can be used to manipulate control of voting results (1 person controls multiple votes that can be cast, effectively “stuffing the ballot box”).

Look at the Warlock Soul Shard Stacking vote.
73% for (16)
27% against (6)
0% abstain (0)

22 of 1812 eligible accounts took part
Where the votes came from — self-reported, not verified

Barrens 4 votes

  • 4 for · 0 against · 0 abstain

Elwynn 18 votes

  • 12 for · 6 against · 0 abstain

Barely anyone voted (18 total on Elwynn), and yet the result of that vote is “binding” on EVERYONE who plays on the Elwynn server.

22 / 1812 = 1.214% of the “electorate” bothered to show up for a vote
16 / 1812 = 0.883% of the “electorate” voted in favor of Warlock Soul Shard Stacking

That’s all it took to overthrow the PROMISE made concerning the Stonetavern vanilla experience.
16 votes in favor, in total.

16 :unamused_face:

“We believe in local control.”
“So long as we control the locals.” :wink:

highering the persantage for a yes is ok,
making the “minimum age” a little higher to vote is ok..

But the moment you start with a point-system you kill the democracy of this project and make it a example of how whole civilacations died…

If you agree with the average opinion thats ok,
if you disagree with the average opinion that is also ok,
but if you have to change the whole system around something 50% of users want, or think of ways how it got manipulated its a “you problem”.

Yeah, one of the worst things was that previous votes were not specific to a single realm and ended up being implemented on both. That’s how the “Vanilla with no changes” concept failed.

Exactly. A perfect example is Los’s vote. He left the server and voted to revert every change back to vanilla, just to screw over the people who actually wanted to keep playing on the server.

When I posted this, I didn’t notice my typo. What I meant was fixing the missing PvE/cross-faction features that should already be working, such as my vote about being able to resurrect players from the opposite faction after they leave their bodies.

Another perfect example is Alizia’s comment on this post. He doesn’t even play on the server anymore, yet somehow still finds the time to share his opinion once a month, despite having absolutely no idea what’s actually going on.
Honestly, I’m just laughing at both his and Los’s comments here and on Discord. It’s quite entertaining watching two people who don’t even understand what others are trying to achieve confidently argue against it.

Honestly, we don’t need any changes to the core mechanics, as they would only take away from the vanilla experience and immersion.

The only QoL changes I can think of that the server is really missing right now are cross-faction PvP queueing for battlegrounds (which wouldn’t break vanilla immersion, since the server is already PvE and cross-faction to begin with).

The other one would be adjusting the AQ War Effort if the player base doesn’t grow, since it wasn’t designed for a population of around 50 players.

What are your thoughts on these two changes, @Starfall? I’m genuinely curious to hear your opinion!

You’re right, but I think the biggest problem right now is that players who have never played Vanilla/Classic can vote on council decisions and push for changes to core mechanics simply because they don’t understand how the game is supposed to work. And this needs to stop.

Players who have at least reached level 60 have had the chance to learn their own class, understand other classes and experience the game as a whole. They’re much less likely to make uninformed decisions that could damage the vanilla experience and immersion, which is one of the main reasons people chose this server in the first place.

Part of the reason why I am so disappointed in the Vanilla experience repudiation of longer duration Paladin Blessings and 5x stacking of Soul Shards for Warlocks.

I personally have no interest in PvP, so it’s probably best for me to abstain with regards to a topic I know almost nothing about (from personal experience).

To be fair, what was the AQ War Effort “really about” (game mechanically, rather than story-wise)? :thinking:

It was really just a Resource Gathering Sink™ (scaled to high server populations) to enable an unlock.

On previous servers I’ve played on, the most “valuable” aspect of the AQ War Effort for ME was the opportunity to raise reputation with my faction’s races. :shushing_face:

Almost all of the item rewards wound up being disenchant/vendor trash for cash, which wasn’t really “necessary” but could occasionally be convenient.

Can’t imagine why. :roll_eyes:
It’s not like I have ALL the answers … :sweat_smile:

Honestly, I’d want more time to contemplate a serious answer, rather than give a flippant reply to this notion (off the cuff). I have the sinking suspicion that any attempt at “Right Sizing” the AQ War Effort is going to wind up with (honest) detractors to the idea (as opposed to just trolling for :sob:, although there will no doubt be some of that too).

I’ve seen other low population servers do something along the lines of an “automatic daily fill” so as to advance the counters by a set MINIMUM amount on a daily basis. That way if there was no participation, advancement towards completion could still happen.

I can’t recommend this option for Elwynn though. :stop_sign:

and peaple get power hungry, i saw it in so so many open-source games : the moment players got anwsers from devs, they started to feel like they can change everything and know whats best with absolutely no idea about the implementation implications that brings with whatever it was… honestly, best would be if the vote resoults are not public : so its a way for the devs to see what the players feel like, but still only have the resposebility to maintain and not to serve…

the reason why 60 is a issue and why that specific and high entry-point for a right to vote is in any political system, imagine: someone doing a self-polices hardcore challange where he only levels with gathering stuff completely pacifistic or whatever crazy stuff ppl do, created and deleted more chars than other put hours into leveling and gearing a hand full 60ies.. why does this guy not deserve a vote? because he is not 60 or because he never killed a world-boss? and if clearly everyone hearing his story would agree he defenetly deserves a vote, then someone has to make a exeption, this sets a precedent more exeptions that not everyone agrees. : you see where im going with this, i think its a mistake that we are in a position where we actually feel like this conversations bares any weight, im thankfull for the devs amintaining this experiance, if i wanted something mroe to my personal liking i host a pirvate server locally with ai-bots.

I like this idea, but still not change the fact that people will make new account get lv10 in an hour and just vote to something they like/don’t like.

True, but do we have people like this on this server? :smiley:

Either way, the council voting system should be reworked or removed entirely. Perhaps we could introduce an idea pool instead, where people can submit suggestions along with their pros and cons. If an idea receives particularly positive feedback and enough support from the community, it could then move forward to an official vote.

exactly, a idea-pool.. more asking for ideas with less responesbility or the idea of power

That’s certainly better than the Council voting method we’ve had so far (with participation levels in voting dropping down to ~1% of the eligible accounts).

Fly the kite first before putting ideas to a “binding” vote.

Agreed.