Right now, pretty much anyone can submit an idea and get it voted through with the help of their friends, regardless of whether the proposed changes are actually good for the server.
New players and players who aren’t familiar with Vanilla/Classic WoW can push for changes that damage the original Vanilla experience simply because they are impatient or don’t understand what made Vanilla special.
When the server launched, its philosophy was clearly stated:
“Pure Classic Vanilla, a Normal PvE realm — faithful 1.12.1, tuned where it was broken and nowhere else.”
Yet here we are, 150 days later, with unnecessary changes that have already driven many players away.
I believe the Council voting system needs to be restructured around player experience, contribution, and trust.
- Voting and proposal eligibility
Players below level 60 should not be allowed to submit proposals or vote in Council polls.
Only established players who have demonstrated a commitment to the server should be able to influence its direction.
- Introduce a player trust system
Players should have a trust score or reputation level that reflects their contributions and the quality of their proposals.
+1 trust point for proposals that are successfully implemented.
-1 trust point for one month for proposals that are rejected or fail to get implemented.
+1 trust point for each PvP rank achieved.
+1 trust point for each raid boss kill.
+1 trust point for each world boss kill.
This would help distinguish players who genuinely want to improve the server from those who simply want to push their personal preferences.
- Prioritize fixing Vanilla features and existing bugs
The Council should prioritize restoring missing features and fixing existing issues rather than constantly introducing unnecessary changes to Vanilla gameplay.
For example:
Fix cross-faction bugs.
Implement missing features that should have been available from day one.
Final thoughts
The Council should exist to improve the server while preserving its original vision, not to turn it into a completely different version of WoW based on whatever changes happen to be popular at the moment.
We joined this server for a Vanilla 1.12.1 experience. The Council should respect and protect that vision.
Posted from the Council — voting happens there; discuss here.