Paladin is a very popular class right now and it makes it almost impossible for shaman to find a group. There are a few options:
Just ignore it. Vanilla has been easy mode for decades at this point, shaman and paladin buffs stacking in leveling dungeons really doesn’t matter. If the plan is to go back to split factions for raiding then there is not raiding implications.
Add code to make shaman totems not work for anyone with an active paladin blessing. This should be the easiest fix and allow the player to choose if they want to use blessing or totems but dispelling any paladin buffs cast on themselves.
Add code to make specific buffs not stack, I think this is how a lot of other servers have handled it. Wisdom/Mana Spring don’t stack and might/strength of earth/grace of air don’t stack. This is a more complete solution but would require more coding.
Posted from the Council — voting happens there; discuss here.
I’m going to cast doubt on this notion. When population (online) is in the double digits, you’re in the “beggars can’t be choosers” range of taking whoever is willing to come along.
This is honestly the simplest “solution” to the question.
This presumes that there are “plenty of groups to go around” and that all of them are going out of their way to exclude Shamans. Either that or not everyone remembers that cross-faction is “allowed” (at present) on Stonetavern, so there’s a presumption that Shamans shouldn’t be invited to Alliance led parties.
If you HAVE TO develop something to deal with the issue, this is the most thorough one. It’s basically a variation of (2), but is something handled server side rather than Player side.
no. ive played with uncoded shaman/paladin stacking it’s absolutely not ok for original vanilla. i do not want nerfed dungeons at lvl 60 this way so it’s not only about raids.
ìt’s hard but probably doable, though crossfaction is temporarily so maybe not worth if it’s very timeconsuming for Innkeeper and would need testing I assume.
I have not seen any other 1.12 server with crossfaction that coded it to not work or overwrite buffs. you said “a lot of other servers have handled it” any example?
If we’re talking about (open world) questing while leveling, remarkably few quests have overlapping objectives between factions (AvH) while leveling, so the “reasonable opportunities” for grouping cross-faction are going to be few and far between, aside from pick up grouping.
If we’re talking about dungeons, quite a few of the early dungeons are “faction biased” for a variety of reasons.
Ragefire Chasm (13-20) … basically a Horde dungeon due to location inside Orgrimmar. There are no Alliance quests for this dungeon.
Wailing Caverns (17-24) … mostly a Horde dungeon due to location in The Barrens, but there are some neutral quest givers so both Alliance and Horde can venture in together (after a LONG WALK for Alliance).
Deadmines (17-26) … mainly an Alliance dungeon due to the lack of quests sending Horde there, while Alliance get a handful of quests.
Shadowfang Keep (20-28) … mostly a Horde dungeon, although Paladins and Warlocks have class quest chains that send them here to gather materials.
Blackfathom Deeps (23-30) … really the first “properly shared” dungeon which has different quest objectives for both Alliance and Horde.
The Stockade (24-32) … basically an Alliance dungeon due to location inside Stormwind. There are no Horde quests for this dungeon.
Gnomeregan (29-38) … mostly an Alliance questing dungeon due to location in Dun Morogh, although there are a few quests the Horde can complete here.
Razorfen Kraul (29-38) … mostly a Horde questing dungeon, although there are some neutral quest givers in Ratchet and a class quest chain will send Warriors here for gathering materials.
Scarlet Monastery (33-44) … everyone gets sent here, eventually. EVERYONE.
Razorfen Downs (37-46) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually, and Alliance casters might want to go here to get the Goldthorn Tea recipe.
Uldamann (38-46) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Maraudon (40-50) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Sunken Temple (44-52) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Blackrock Depths (48-56) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Blackrock Spire (55-60) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Dire Maul (56-60) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Stratholme (56-60) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
Scholomance (58-60) … everyone also gets sent here, eventually.
My point in making this list of dungeons is to demonstrate that among the “early” dungeons in Vanilla, only Wailing Caverns, Shadowfang Keep and Blackfathom Deeps have cross-faction “appeal” until reaching the Scarlet Monastery. That’s only 3 out of 8 dungeons prior to Scarlet Monastery, which can cause a statistical skew in the grouping opportunities until the dungeons become more “cross-faction friendly” at higher levels (from the mid-30s onwards).
Pile that on top of a small (but friendly!) community of Players with alts scattershot around levels and objectives and you wind up with a situation in which the reason why Shamans aren’t getting invited into groups can’t be entirely laid at the feet of (popular? ) Paladins. Partially yes, but entirely no. Small clique group dynamics (play with Friends You Know) could be a larger factor than mere game mechanics.
This is the whole point, if there are only 5 people online in level range for a dungeon and one of them is a paladin and one is a shaman then they can’t group up to run that dungeon.
If there are 5 people in the level range for a dungeon … at lower levels cross-faction dungeon running isn’t as easy/enticing due to the bias of dungeon questing (until reaching BFD and SFK which can have some cross-communication of quest objectives, so mixed dungeon grouping can make sense). At higher levels (SM onwards) that issue “falls by the wayside” as everyone gets sent to the same dungeons.
However, if you’re wanting to run The Stockades … granted, no Shamans are going to want to join that party (because, inside Stormwind).
What I’m not grasping is the notion of if Paladin=yes then Shaman=no in ALL circumstances, regardless of context. If cross-faction grouping IS ALLOWED (and on Stonetavern it is), this shouldn’t be a problem or an issue caused by the classes being inherently incompatible with each other (somehow).
Conversely, if there’s a faction population imbalance (many Alliance, few Horde) making it difficult for Shamans to find groups to run dungeons with, that’s a faction population issue rather than a “Paladins are taking all the group spots” problem.
For early dungeons, 5 of the 8 are going to suffer from the “square peg, round hole” issue (as I alluded to previously, upthread) when it comes to cross-faction party opportunities. That’s going to bias impressions of opportunities for grouping until reaching higher levels.
If the buffs can’t be disabled, oh well. What is really going to be broken? In 1.12 talents and gear, on 20 year old game content.
Double mp5 buff? the horror! Windfury to boost ret’s viability? Hey not bad.. but if you’re against that then how is it ok for alliance warriors/rogues to benefit from windfury also?
I feel that leaving out a whole group of players to avoid these is not beneficial on a low pop server. It would be nice if you could make the buffs not stack but it’s not all that game breaking to have them.