Reverse all changes

Reverse all changes stop with the council and back to TRUE classic


Posted from the Council — voting happens there; discuss here.

I’m inclined to agree … but not on an all or nothing basis.
At least not for Elwynn server.
Some of the changes have been beneficial.

I’ll go through the Decided Votes and mention the ones that have introduced changes to Elwynn to explain the nuances of my position more thoroughly.

  • Disable low levels being able to camp chests in high level zones
    • Desirable change.
  • Recommended PvP Ranking Changes for Elwynn
    • Understandable change. Limited population of PvP participation puts a pretty hard limit on PvP rank advancement opportunities.
  • Warlock soul shard stacking
    • Undesirable change. I honestly wish this had NOT been implemented on the Elwynn server. It is explicitly anti-Vanilla and is something that I feel SHOULD be reverted out on Elwynn server. Barrens server is a different context, and I’m not playing at all on the Barrens server, so I won’t presume to speak for them.
  • XP Lock
    • Understandable change. More of a PvE “self-gimp” option, which then becomes desirable for PvP bracket play. Since it is something self-inflicted (on purpose), I’m okay with it.
  • Keep the in-game experience vanilla as much as possible
    • Not exactly a “change” per se, but definitely a benchmark to live by.
  • Meeting Stones as summoning stones
    • Understandable change. Personally I’m not that happy about it, but I can understand it. The biggest difference it makes is saving Player Time (the most valuable resource!), rather than creating Unfair Advantages for select Players.
  • Disable World Buffs in raids entirely
    • Desirable change.
  • Paladin’s Blessing Duration
    • Undesirable change. Yes it’s nice. Yes it’s convenient. But since I’m playing alts of all 9 classes in parallel on Elwynn server, it feels wrong/biased for Paladins to get 10 minute buffs while Shaman weapon enchant buffs remain stuck at 5 minutes. I honestly wish that this buff could be reverted.
  • Increased chance for rare bosses/minibosses in Dungeons
    • Desirable change. With limited population, it’s hard enough to recruit for 5-man dungeon runs already. Intermittent spawns of rare bosses/minibosses in dungeons makes a lot more sense on well to highly populated servers in which recruiting for 5-man dungeon runs can be something of a non-problem.
  • Auction time
    • Desirable change, due to the limited population of Elwynn server.
  • Party’s item quest sharing
    • Desirable change.
  • Allow purchasing legacy mounts until Phase II
    • Honestly, I’m in favor of keeping the legacy mounts available forever, so that Players who join later/start alts later aren’t “penalized” by not starting fast enough/leveling fast enough to obtain these legacy mounts.
  • Instant mail for all
    • Understandable change.
  • Revisit Shaman/Paladin grouping
    • Understandable change.
  • AH Changes for low population
    • Desirable change.
  • Adjusted Reset Talent costs
    • Desirable change.

So out of ALL of the changes made to Elwynn server after votes by the Council, I would personally dispute only TWO of the results as being undesirable/bad precedent that should be reverted.

Although I am voting Elwynn: YES on this proposal, as the above itemization details that is because of the Paladin Buff and Warlock Shards issues that I feel have been wrongly decided and should be reverted. All other changes that have been voted upon are either Understandable or Desirable in my view … and thus should NOT be reversed or undone.

Hope that helps the Innkeeper. :sweat_smile:

This Council vote post is something its creator clearly hasn’t thought through. It’s obvious that they don’t fully understand the impact of some of the proposed changes. It also comes from someone who stopped playing on this server and went back to Retail, seemingly wanting to screw things up on their way out (according to one of his friends).

Your post about the AV changes proves my point: no one cares about the materials in AV. It was stated from the beginning that guild battlegrounds would focus on PvP progression and AV reputation farming, and you haven’t even participated in any of these events.

Unnecessary changes have to stop, and I think everyone can agree on that! However, if we want people to enjoy the game as they did in Vanilla, some changes are necessary until the server population reaches the threshold where those changes can be reverted.

Starfall, I think you did an awesome job summarizing this! I 100% agree with you. Some changes need to go, such as Paladin blessings, summoning stones, and Soul Shard stacking.

However, there are also changes that are beneficial without breaking the Vanilla experience, such as the AH changes, XP locking, rare spawns in dungeons (we don’t have players running dungeons 24/7 to farm rares), instant mail, and, most importantly, reduced respec costs.

The last point is especially important because, with the server’s low population, dual-role players often have to respec multiple times a week just to heal or tank a dungeon, depending on which role is missing.

Since I don’t PvP, I was unaware of what was going on in this scene. But if people are trying to “corner the market” on PvP by controlling access, that does seem to be something that ought to be investigated by Staff under the heading of Abusive Anti-competitive Behavior (or words to that effect) in the PvP arenas.

I agree that some of the recent requests for changes have felt … unbalancing … in the sense that they (intentionally) disrupt the Balance Point that the game is meant to be balanced around.

Ah yes, the “burn it all down on the way out the door” routine.

Agreed.

“We do what we must, because, we can.” :headphone:

Those are just too much of a deviation from the baseline Vanilla to “feel right” to me.

Not ALL changes are default BAD™.
However, some of the changes that have been put to the Council votes and pushed Live most certainly have been BAD™ (in my opinion) for the longer term health of the server and its community.